Lore: Arcana

lore/magic lore/cosmology status/draft

“My lord asked whether the working was real or a trick. I told him yes.” — a house reckoner, after a Saltmere supper

GM reference. Ground truth, except where marked as what people say. What the coast actually knows is in the practitioners’ theories, the patrons’ habits and the street names.


🔥 What the Arcane is

When the mortals rose against their makers, they stole the magic and science of their creators and used it to kill them (see Cosmology - The Great Fracture). The science survives as a trade: the Guild of Alchemists holds it under seal, split between masters so that no one person carries the whole. The magic did not survive as anything. What was a working whole before the Deicide is now fragments scattered across the Disk, and nobody alive has more than a handful.

An Arcanist is someone who has pieced enough of those fragments together to make some of them work. None of them knows why. Each holds a theory of what the fragments are and why they answer, and each theory is partly right: right enough to work, wrong enough to fail in ways its holder can’t explain.

GM-facing. No practitioner’s theory is the truth, and no two agree, because each was built from different fragments of the same stolen whole. A working that fits a practitioner’s theory goes cleanly. One that doesn’t still works, but it costs them, because they are doing something their own understanding cannot account for. The Arcane has nobody on the other end. A priest borrows from a Domain that is still there and still collecting; an Arcanist uses the stolen tool itself, and the cost lands on the hand that holds it.

🪨 The fragments

Practitioners learn from whatever survived. They prize the fragments themselves almost as much as what can be learned from them.

  • Inscriptions. Tablets, carved lintels, the margins of ruins. The oldest are elven, and the elves who could read them are mostly dead. Marren Loweb, one of the Seven, could read the script in the temple under Corvus Spire well enough to know the door could not be shut from this side (see Duchy of Corvus).
  • Paintings. Diagrams on cave walls and barrow stones, older than writing, copied by candlelight and argued over for generations.
  • The bones. The war-bone that Longbarrow ploughs up every spring, and the petrified remains under the city, still bleeding unanchored energy into the stone. A practitioner who can read a bone’s grain can sometimes read what it was for.
  • Quickened pieces. Wrack that has half-woken. Fey are essence that quickened in still water; these are shards of unanchored wrack that quickened a little and stopped. They turn in the hand, warm to one person and not another, and behave as though they want something. Practitioners call them quick-things. They are the rarest fragments and the most argued over, and a practitioner who owns one is rarely the only party with an interest in it.

GM-facing. Quick-things are natural Relics: unique, GM-authored, and each one with a want of its own.

📓 The Grimoire

A Grimoire is not a printed book of spells. It is a practitioner’s own working notebook: rubbings of tablets, copied diagrams, star-tables, the owner’s notes in the owner’s notation, and pages of failed attempts kept because they were nearly right.

  • Why Arcanists study every night. A working cannot be memorised the way a song can. It has to be re-derived from the notes, and it holds in the head for about a day before it slips. A practitioner who misses a night can still read straight from the page, slowly and with the book open in one hand.
  • Why one Grimoire is useless to another reader. The notation is private. A stolen Grimoire is a puzzle in someone else’s handwriting, and copying from one is closer to decoding a cipher than to transcribing a text.
  • Vane’s Book. The most copied Grimoire on the coast, attributed to Vane, a practitioner from before living memory. Copies have passed hand to hand for generations, each copyist correcting what they thought was wrong, and no two now agree. “Which Vane do you work from?” is a real question, and the answer places a practitioner the way a family name places a stranger.

🎩 The kept Arcanist

Wealthy houses keep an Arcanist on staff. The practical reasons are real: someone to read the Low Moons for a voyage, find a seam, ward a strongroom, or say what a dead man’s quick-thing is for. But the social reason is the one that sets the price. A practitioner in the household, giving a demonstration after supper, is one of the clearest signs on the coast that a house can afford anything.

  • Not an Envoy. A Golden Company Envoy is hired from the Company, which vets them, sets the rate and stands behind them. An Arcanist has nothing behind them, so a patron must find one. The prestige is in the finding: in rarity, in reputation, and in lineage (“ours works from a Vane copy two hands removed from the original”).
  • The price. There is no Company to set the rate. A sought-after practitioner costs more than an Envoy’s 15–25 gold sovereigns a season, and houses poach each other’s.
  • Disputations. A house’s Arcanist and a rival house’s argue opposing theories before guests, then each does a working to prove their case. Guests wager on the result. It is the coast’s most fashionable entertainment that a duke cannot buy outright.
  • Titles. Households give their Arcanists titles: Reckoner to the House, Philosopher, Archmage. The titles mean nothing outside the house that gave them, and the street knows it. Archmage is a vanity title that some forgotten household gave Vane, and it stuck.
  • The houses. The Valerius and Aerthos courts, which already keep Envoys for show, compete for Arcanists the same way. Duke Tythius De Vonce refuses to retain an Envoy on principle, and he would not hire an Arcanist either. His house grew its own: Imaihil De Vonce keeps the library at Iron-Spire, corresponds with the Guild’s Chapter-House about its moon-tables, and twice has gone to the edge of the Scar to bring back soil and water in stoppered jars (see Duchy of De Vonce).

GM-facing. One De Vonce did hire an Arcanist. Eldrick kept one behind his father’s back, on his captains’ books, to run the weapon tests in the upper Sisters, and the man died when a test went wrong (see Duchy of De Vonce). He is the one kept Arcanist on the coast whose patron never showed him to anyone.

🤝 Hands and correspondences

There are no colleges, towers or orders of Arcanists, and never have been on this coast.

  • A hand. One practitioner and one or two wards who copy their master’s notation and learn to read it. When the master dies, the wards inherit the Grimoire and spend years arguing over what it meant.
  • A correspondence. Practitioners who have never met, writing to one another across the coast and beyond it: sharing rubbings, disputing readings, asking whether anyone else has seen what they have seen. A dead practitioner’s papers usually include half of somebody else’s correspondence.
  • Why no schools. Because there is no body of knowledge to teach, only notebooks, and because of Corvus. The Undercourt was the nearest thing the coast ever had to a school of the Arcane: a gathering of practitioners around one source, the temple’s script, grown large enough to open a door. Since 8 A.A., a practitioner who starts gathering students finds the Zenith asking polite questions about who they are and what they are for. Practising draws no such attention. Gathering does.

🧪 Charlatans and demonstration

Most of the “arcanists” in the Muddy Docks are frauds: horoscopes, tonics, a lodestone painted to look like wrack. The public knows it, which is why the real thing proves itself in public. A practitioner who wants to be believed does something in front of witnesses, and the best of them have made demonstration an art: the dinner-table working, the disputation, the wager won. Half-awed and half-sceptical is the coast’s normal mood towards the Arcane, and practitioners have learned to work it.

🧭 The traditions

Every practitioner’s theory is their own, but theories cluster, and the street has names for the clusters. Practitioners rarely use them.

TraditionStreet nameWhat its practitioners sayWho takes an interest
AstromancyreckonersThe moons are lamps hung by the makers, and their light still carries the last workings; reckon the angle and you can read it, or borrow it.Nobody objects. The Guild’s observatory does this work under another name.
PyromancyburnersFire is not made but let out. Every thing holds a latent fire, and a working opens the door it is kept behind.The Guild’s Searchers. Fire without powder cuts into the powder monopoly: a guild quarrel, not a persecution.
NecromancytwitchersEvery bone keeps a current, freshest in the newly dead. War-bone keeps the most, and it can be made to run again.The Ashen Veil, openly.
TransmutationhumouristsEvery substance is a balance of humours. Rebalance it and it becomes something else.The Tidespoken, who see the hags’ trade in it.
Shadow Sorceryglass-readersA shadow or a reflection is a second thing, not a copy, and it can be made to act.Nobody objects. The Crooked Coin keeps an eye on the good ones.
Demonology & VoidnamersA thing’s true name is its handle. Name it rightly and it must answer.Everyone who remembers Corvus. The one tradition still carrying a stigma.
Witch Magic & Hedge Craftcunning folkLike answers like: a root shaped like a hand heals hands, and a likeness can be made to suffer for its original. Much of it was learned from hags, for a price.The Tidespoken, for the same reason as Transmutation.
Shamanism—Not written down. Carried in song and skin-mark by the people of the high Spine, who lived there before the settlers (see The Cult of the Rime-Fang). Book-learned practitioners envy it and misread it. Song and skin-mark serve its practitioners as a Grimoire serves anyone else.Nobody. Few outside the Spine know it exists.

GM-facing.

  • Shadow Sorcery works because a reflection is still, faintly, the province of the Two-Faced, the Creator of reflection (see Cosmology - The Celestial Graveyard and The war of Creation). Glass-readers do not know this.
  • Demonology works by naming, and naming was the original wound: the Naming gave the nameless entities their identities. The namers are repeating the first crime in miniature, and the Undercourt took it to its end.
  • Necromancy’s current is real; it is the essence still bleeding from bone — a little from the newly dead, a great deal from unanchored war-bone.
  • The one exception to the Arcane having nobody on the other end is Shamanism. What the Spine’s shamans call spirits are ghosts the Unmoving held, and they answer because they are still there.
  • Measurers count any working, Arcane or Prayer, as something forced off its line, and a spell cast in sight of a dormant one wakes it (see Lore - The War-Made). Practitioners who work near old ruins learn to look hard at the statues first. Most learn it the other way.

⚖️ The Arcane and the law

The Edicts of Armament say nothing about Grimoires, and no magistrate has yet tried to make them (see Law - The Council's Edicts). An Arcanist walks the city as freely as anyone else of their class. A kept Arcanist walks it a good deal more freely, with a house’s name behind them.

The Mote: Every practitioner on the coast is working from someone else’s handwriting, and every one of them adds a page. Nobody has ever burned a Grimoire they inherited. They argue with it instead.


❓ Open questions — TheTao’s call

  • Is Imaihil De Vonce an Arcanist? He does everything one does, and calls it scholarship. Does his father know?
  • Who was Vane, and which household made him an Archmage?
  • Does anyone hold an original fragment of Vane’s Book, and would they show it?
  • Do Arcanists have a legal standing of any kind (a patron’s letter, a household seal), or is the house’s name protection enough?
  • The Spine people’s own name for what the street calls Shamanism.
  • The Fourth. Did the old empire across the Broken Ocean keep the Arcane better than the coast did?

Cosmology - The Great Fracture · The Guild of Alchemists · Lore - Hags · The Golden Company · Duchy of De Vonce

Crunch: Arcane casting, Paradigms, Grimoires and study have rules in the Iron & Marrow ruleset (Embracing the Abyss; Manipulating the Void). Per the canon tracker’s blend rule, the mechanics live in the ruleset and are not restated here. A patron as a Downtime relationship is needs crunch.