To keep the two systems distinct, we should root them in entirely opposite philosophies: Arcana is about Volatility and Margins, while Faith is about Certainty and Sacrifice.
”Spell” is the generic term
Spell covers both forms of magic. An Arcane working and a Faith Prayer are both spells, and any rule that says spell applies to both — unless the surrounding rule is explicitly scoped to one, as the Arcane Sustain rules and the Faith Flowing rules below are. Where a rule must name one side alone it says Arcane spell or Prayer, and the corpus already does so wherever it matters.
What this settles in play: anything that wards against, resists, counters or detects spells works against hostile Prayers as readily as hostile Arcana. Arcane Protection is the worked example — an Arcane ward whose protection extends to divine magic.
Casting Difficulty by Spell Level (Tiered TN)
Unopposed casting checks — the Margin of Manifestation roll, a Sustain check, and a Priest’s Tithe of Will — no longer target a flat TN 8. The Target Number is set by the spell or Prayer’s own Level:
| Level | TN |
|---|---|
| Novice | 8 |
| Adept | 10 |
| Master | 12 |
This does not apply to Arcane Clash spells or any other opposed roll — both sides already scale together, so there’s no static-TN problem to fix. It also does not apply to general skill checks outside of spellcasting; those take their TN from the GM Tools difficulty ladder, which uses these same four rungs. A Sustain check always targets the TN of the specific spell being sustained.
(Note: Faith’s Prayer tiers are Novice / Adept / Master, matching Arcana’s naming exactly — the tier previously labeled “Apprentice” is renamed to Adept throughout, so both systems read off the same table above.)
Arcana (The Volatile Margin)
Arcana is the act of forcefully rewriting reality. It is highly complex, mathematically devastating, and inherently volatile. It relies entirely on Margin mechanics.
The Casting Requirements (The Book, the Study and the Hand)
An Arcanist’s spells live in their Grimoire, and in their head only for as long as the book allows. The working itself is a physical act. Casting an Arcane spell requires two things:
- Spells held. The Arcanist studied their Grimoire at their last Long Rest (see Study, below), and every spell in it is held in memory.
- A hand free, to trace the somatic geometry of the working — or a held item carrying the Conduit tag, which traces it for them (Hardware: Arcane Focus).
Once its spells are held, the Grimoire does not need to be in hand, or even on the Arcanist’s person. It is needed to study, and to read from.
Study. During a Long Rest, an Arcanist spends 1 hour with their Grimoire. The hour sits inside the Long Rest’s 8 hours — reading is not strenuous — and needs a light to read by: a fire, a lantern, daylight, anything but Pitch Black (Iron World — Illumination). At the conclusion of the Long Rest, every spell in the Grimoire is held until the conclusion of the Arcanist’s next Long Rest. A Depleted Supply Die does not stop the study on its own; read it in context. A Depleted party with no light of its own — no fuel for a fire, no oil for a lantern, camped on a no-moon night — has nothing to read by, and the study cannot happen.
Reading from the page. An Arcanist whose spells are not held — the study was missed, there was no light, the book came back too late — can still cast from the open Grimoire: the book wielded in one hand exactly as a 1H weapon, and the other hand free or holding a Conduit item. With the book not in hand, an Arcanist whose spells are not held cannot cast at all, except a spell kept by Ingrained Arcana.
Losing the Grimoire. Spells already held stay held until the conclusion of the next Long Rest. After that, with no book to study, the Arcanist keeps only what Ingrained Arcana keeps. A lost, stolen or Sundered Grimoire is a deadline, not a switch.
Blind Casting. Casting with no hand free and no Conduit item in hand — whether from held spells or reading from the page — is Blind Casting: the check is made at Disadvantage, and the caster takes 1 Dissonant Stress.
An Arcanist’s loadout is a real build decision (see Hardware: Arcane Focus):
| Loadout | Spells | Hand | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| One hand empty; the other holds a weapon, shield or sling | Held | Met | Clean. |
| Wand (Conduit, Sidearm) in one hand | Held | Met | Clean, and Sidearm lifts the Point-Blank Disadvantage on the cast. |
| Vitrified Wand (Conduit, Focus) in one hand | Held | Met | Clean, +1 to the Clash. Enchanted — 1 Locked Stress. |
| Mage Staff (Conduit) | Held | Met | Clean, plus Reach and Sustain support. Both hands committed. |
| Weapon carrying Conduit, shield in the other hand | Held | Met | Clean. The weapon stands in for the free hand. |
| Weapon and shield, neither carrying Conduit | Held | Unmet | Blind Casting: Disadvantage, 1 Dissonant Stress per cast. |
| Grimoire open in one hand, other hand empty | Not held | Met | Clean, read from the page. |
| Grimoire not in hand | Not held | — | Cannot cast (except Ingrained Arcana). |
Casting at Point-Blank. An enemy inside your Threat Zone imposes Disadvantage on the cast, exactly as it does on a shot (Metal meet Flesh — Ranges), unless your Arcane Focus carries the Sidearm tag. A spell’s listed range band is a cap rather than a minimum, so Point-Blank is always a legal distance to cast at — it is simply a bad one. This is Disadvantage from position; Blind Casting above is Disadvantage from loadout. Blind Casting’s Dissonant Stress is still owed on its own account, but the Disadvantage from the two does not stack — Disadvantage never does (Iron Core).
The Arcane Clash (Combat Spells)
When an Arcanist casts an offensive spell that deals Impact, calculate it the same way a weapon does:
Impact = (Margin of the Clash, or Margin over the spell’s own TN for an unopposed spell) + Spell Power
Each spell’s entry lists a flat Spell Power rating, exactly like a weapon’s Power. The Margin Scaler doesn’t define the Impact number directly — it defines the special effect that comes with each tier (a condition, a debuff, a status).
Spell Power by Level. Spell Power is set by the spell’s tier and sits on the same rungs as weapon Power (0 / 2 / 3 / 5), so a spell and a blade are always priced against each other:
Level Spell Power Novice 2 Adept 3 Master 5 Reduce Spell Power by 1 if the spell applies its Impact to a zone, to multiple targets, or persists across rounds — breadth and duration are paid for out of the same budget as raw force. A spell that deals no Impact at all lists no Spell Power. Deviations from this table are permitted but should be justified in the spell’s own entry, not left silent.
Clash Margin Costs (every Clash spell, Overcharged or not): A Margin 1–2 result costs the caster 1 Dissonant Stress — this is the Clash-spell equivalent of the Margin of Manifestation’s Messy Success, and it’s the tier Paradigm Mastery upgrades to Margin 3+ (Clean) for in-Paradigm casters, paying no cost. Margin 3+ (Clean) costs nothing. Losing the Clash outright (the target’s roll is higher) costs nothing beyond the lost action — same as whiffing a mundane Strike, you only pay to land a rough hit, not to miss. The Snake Eyes Backfire (natural double-1s: 1 Wound + 1 Dissonant Stress + a battlefield hazard) applies to any Arcana casting roll, Clash or unopposed, exactly as it already does for the Margin of Manifestation.
Overcharge: Once per casting, before resolving the Clash, an Arcanist may Lock 1 Stress to add +2 to that spell’s Spell Power or the Margin scaler for this casting only.
Defense : When a spell’s resolution reads “vs. Target’s Defense,” the target rolls 2d6 + the most relevant Reactor action available to them — typically Block, Dodge, or Brace, exactly as if they were defending against a weapon Strike. “Defense” is shorthand for “the target picks their best applicable Reactor roll,” not a separate derived stat the target has sitting on their sheet.
The Margin of Manifestation (Utility Spells)
When casting an unopposed spell (like Levitate or Shatter Lock), the Arcanist rolls against that spell’s Target Number, set by its Level per the Tiered TN table above. The spell’s effectiveness is entirely dictated by the Margin.
- Failure (below the spell’s TN): The spell fails. The Arcanist takes 1 Dissonant Stress.
- Messy Success (Margin 0–2): The spell works, but with dangerous collateral. The lock shatters, but the noise alerts the dungeon. The fire lights, but it catches the caster’s sleeve. The caster takes 1 dissonant stress.
- Clean Success (Margin 3–4): The spell works exactly as intended.
- Massive (Margin 5+): The spell overcharges, generating 1 Momentum.
The “Snake Eyes” Backfire (Natural 2)
They immediately take 1 physical Wound (as their flesh chemically burns) AND 1 Dissonant Stress, and the spell produces a lethal hazard on the battlefield.
2. The Arcanist’s Gamble (Pushing the Math)
To give Arcanists a tactical choice similar to the Priest’s sacrifice, we can introduce Blood Channelling.
- Before rolling an Arcane check, the Arcanist can voluntarily take 1 Dissonant Stress (cutting their palm, inhaling toxic fumes) to gain Advantage on their roll.
- This allows them to push the math to guarantee hitting TN 8 or to ensure a massive margin in a Clash, but it pushes them incredibly close to the Death Spiral.
Reactor Spells (Defensive Magic)
To make “Cast Spell” a valid Reactor Action, you need a specific category of spells designed to be cast in a split second.
- Arcane Reactions (The Opposed Clash): Deflection is the worked example. It triggers the moment the caster becomes the target of an attack — it is cast as a Reactor action with nothing raised in advance — and resolves as an Opposed Clash using
2d6 + Arcanaagainst the attack’s own roll. Winning negates the attack outright; the Margin then sets what the ward leaves behind, per the spell’s own entry. Not every defensive spell works this way: Arcane Protection must be raised ahead of time as an Activation and can never be thrown up in reaction — its Reactor action is for using a ward already standing, not for casting one. - Faith Reactions (The Stress Soak): Because Faith magic bypasses the dice, a Priest’s Reactor spell (like Martyr’s Shield) wouldn’t require a Clash roll. Instead, when an enemy rolls an attack, the Priest declares the Prayer, instantly accepts 1 or 2 Locked Stress, and immediately grants themselves or an ally a massive Front-End Reducer (e.g., +4 Shield Value) against that specific attack.
- Fixed-Duration Buffs: For spells like Calcify Armour that grant an ongoing +1 SV, the player does not need to use the “Cast Spell” Reactor Action. The magic is already active. When attacked, they simply choose the “Block” or “Brace” action and mathematically benefit from the buffed stats.
The Channelling Rule Certain powerful, ongoing spells and Prayers (like Wildfire Proliferation or Sanctuary) carry an ongoing duration. Arcane spells call this Sustain; Faith Prayers call it Flowing. A caster can only maintain one such effect at a time, regardless of which system it comes from. (Correction: this previously cited “Litany of Nails” as the Flowing example — that’s the Zealot’s Tier 2 Archetype Feat name from The Marrow, not a Prayer, and it isn’t listed in any Domain.)
Neither Sustain nor Flowing costs Locked Stress. An Arcanist pays for concentration in Dissonant Stress, rolled for turn by turn; a Priest has already paid their Locked Stress at the moment of casting and owes nothing further. Locked Stress is not the currency of holding a spell open in either system.
-
The Arcane Cost (Volatility) — Sustain: To keep an Arcane spell active, the Arcanist must dedicate their concentration. They roll
2d6 + Arcana vs. the spell's own TNat two moments: at the start of their Activation, before they move or act, and immediately upon taking a Wound. The check resolves on the standard Margin of Manifestation ladder:- Fail (below the spell’s TN): The spell drops, and the Arcanist takes 1 Dissonant Stress from the magical backfire.
- Messy (Margin 0–2): The spell holds, but the strain shows — the Arcanist takes 1 Dissonant Stress.
- Clean or Massive (Margin 3+): The spell holds at no cost.
Because this is a Margin of Manifestation roll, Paradigm Mastery applies: an in-Paradigm spell treats a Messy sustain as Clean, and the specialist channels almost indefinitely for free. An off-Paradigm or Common spell bleeds the caster a little every round. (This also makes Fevered Channelling highly valuable.)
Being knocked Prone does not force a Sustain check. Arcane channelling is an act of mental concentration — pain interrupts it, posture does not.
-
The Faith Cost (Sacrifice) — Flowing: The divine connection requires absolute physical devotion. If the Priest takes a Wound or is knocked Prone, the Flowing Prayer instantly drops, no roll permitted. The Priest also rolls the Tithe of Will each Activation to maintain their grip — see Flowing (Maintaining a Prayer), below.
Faith (The Somatic Sacrifice)
Faith is not about channelling chaotic energy; it is about borrowing divine or eldritch authority. It is highly reliable but physically destroys the caster from the inside out.
The Tithe of Will
Faith magic is not a gamble against failure — it is a negotiation with the price. When a Priest declares a Prayer, the Prayer always happens. What the dice determine is not whether the Priest succeeds, but whose hand is actually on the wheel: theirs, or the entity they’re borrowing power from.
-
The Mechanic: When declaring a Prayer, the Priest rolls 2d6 + Faith vs. the Prayer’s own TN, set by its Level per the Tiered TN table above. This is not a Margin-Scaler roll — there is no Messy/Clean/Massive ladder, and there is no Failure state that prevents the Prayer from occurring. The roll only ever determines the cost.
-
Pass (meets or exceeds the Prayer’s TN) — Clean Channel: The Priest’s own faith and discipline carry the weight. The Prayer occurs exactly as written, and the Priest pays the Locked Stress cost listed for that Prayer. Nothing else happens. This is the expected, unremarkable outcome for a Priest who knows their scripture.
-
Fail (below the Prayer’s TN) — Borrowed Authority: The Prayer still occurs — full effect, no exceptions — but the power moves through the Priest rather than from them. The Priest pays the standard Locked Stress cost, exactly as on a Pass, and gains 1 point of Encroachment (see below). This is not a punishment for bad luck; it is the fictional truth of the system finally showing its teeth — the Priest doesn’t actually control what they’re invoking, they just have working enough faith to ask nicely.
-
Snake Eyes (Natural 2) — The Toll in Flesh: The Prayer still occurs. But whatever the Priest is channeling decides the mind has paid enough for today, and takes the rest out of the body instead. Convert the Prayer’s entire Locked Stress cost into an equal number of points of direct Wound damage (bypassing Wound Threshold entirely, per the Direct Wounds rule), rather than Locked Stress. A Priest who Snake-Eyes a 2-Stress Prayer takes the full toll across 2 Wound slots’ worth of damage instead — this is the stigmata, the shattered bone, the bleeding from the eyes the system has always promised, given an actual trigger condition instead of being purely narrative flavor. The entity considers this payment made in full: reset the Priest’s Encroachment to 0, regardless of its current value.
- The Cap: A single Toll in Flesh conversion cannot inflict more than 3 direct Wounds, regardless of the Prayer’s Locked Stress cost — this is the existing Wound Slot ceiling (Iron Core), not a new number. This keeps a bad roll on a Master Prayer brutal (it empties every Wound Slot a character has) without being an unconditional Incapacitation from full health. A Prayer’s own entry can explicitly override this cap when its fictional weight demands it (see Resurrection, Manipulating the Void) — the cap is the default, not an absolute.
-
Fate’s Bounty (Natural 12): As with any other check, the Priest banks 2 Momentum — no die is added to the total. This cannot change whether the Prayer happens (it already was going to), but a Priest who rolls a 12 treats the result as an automatic Pass, whatever threshold the specific Prayer would otherwise have measured them against (GM’s discretion for Prayers with scaling effects).
Encroachment (The Running Tab)
Stress isn’t the only thing a Fail costs a Priest — it also costs them a little more of the entity’s attention. Track it on 3 Encroachment slots, separate from any Stress track, filled the way Wound Slots are. Wherever the rules say a Priest “gains 1 Encroachment”, fill 1 slot; “clears 1 Encroachment” empties 1 slot; “resets Encroachment to 0” empties them all.
- Whenever a Priest Fails a Tithe of Will — on a fresh cast or a Flowing check — they fill 1 Encroachment slot, in addition to paying the normal Locked Stress cost.
- Encroachment never modifies a dice roll. Filled slots sit on the sheet as a silent tally, exactly the way Locked Stress does — they cost nothing until the Priest runs out of room.
- The Tab Comes Due: when a Priest must fill an Encroachment slot and has none left empty, the entity collects all at once. The Priest pays their Domain’s Price (see Domain Prices, below), and all 3 slots clear. A Priest bound to no Domain — the Heretic’s Path or a Ritualist — has no single current claiming them, so nothing in particular collects: they suffer 1 direct Wound (bypassing Wound Threshold, per the Direct Wounds rule) instead.
- Encroachment does not clear on its own, and a Breather cannot touch it, per the Breather’s existing limitation that it cannot clear Locked Stress — Encroachment is treated the same way. It only clears when the Tab Comes Due, on a Snake Eyes result (see Toll in Flesh), or by a successful Religious Pursuit (see Downtime).
Why roll at all, if the Prayer never fails?
Because reliability was never the same thing as safety. The Arcanist risks failure — a botched spell, a wasted turn, a Snake-Eyes explosion that hurts everyone nearby. The Priest never risks failure, and the Stress cost is the same whether they Pass or Fail — but every single Prayer is still a coin flip between “I paid the toll myself, cleanly” and “I paid it, but the thing on the other end remembers.” A Fail doesn’t hurt any worse in the moment than a Pass does; it’s a mark against the Priest personally, one that has nothing to do with the party’s fortunes and everything to do with how many times this specific channel has slipped. A party with a Priest who keeps rolling badly isn’t watching the dungeon get hungrier — they’re watching their healer quietly run up a debt that whatever they’ve been borrowing from will, eventually, collect on in blood.
Domain Prices
Every Domain is a different current, and each one collects in its own coin. When the tab comes due, a Covenant Priest pays the Price of their Domain — whichever list the failing Prayer came from, Common Prayers included, because it is the Priest’s own current that has been keeping count. None of these Prices modifies a roll. Each is a condition, a restriction or a mark: the cost is what becomes true, not a number.
| Domain | When the tab comes due | The lasting change |
|---|---|---|
| Strategy | Holding, until the end of the scene. The Priest cannot Disengage, cannot move away from the nearest enemy, and cannot take the Regroup action to withdraw. They are immune to Fear and Terrified while it lasts. An NPC Priest who Breaks while Holding resolves as Frenzy, never Rout. | They no longer remember how to retreat. |
| Trickery | The GM holds a Reversal. Once before the Priest’s next Long Rest, the GM may turn one roll the Priest has just succeeded on into a failure, after it is rolled. Unused at the Long Rest, it lapses. | Luck always collects. |
| Law | Until the end of the scene, the Priest is Blinded (Iron Core) toward every creature whose name they have not heard spoken or seen written. Named creatures are seen as normal. | One person they knew who was never written down — named by the player — whose face they can no longer picture. |
| Death | The Quiet Keeps a Place. The fight goes out of them: every Flowing Prayer they hold ends, and their Momentum Bank empties. And they record one held Death Mark (maximum two). A held Mark does nothing until the next time the Priest is Incapacitated: they begin the Bleed-Out Check (Iron Core, At Death’s Door) with it already filled. Held Marks clear only when spent — if the Priest survives that Bleed-Out (Stabilized by their own checks or by Triage), all held Marks are gone. Religious Pursuit does not reach them. | It waits. |
| Winter & Wilds | The Priest gains Rigor. They are also Cold to the Touch until their next Long Rest: no ally’s action, Prayer or feat can clear their Stress, and nothing they do clears anyone else’s. | A little less feeling for someone they love. |
| Mercy & Healing | The Priest pays nothing — they clear 1 Locked Stress, as vigour arrives from somewhere. The last character the Priest healed (most recently, in this scene or any other) gains 1 Grey: a permanent tally on that character’s sheet. Greys never clear, and they come due at Death’s Door (Iron Core — Greys). | The patient’s, not the Priest’s. |
| Sea & Storms | The tide takes one thing the Priest holds: one item in their hands or on their Belt, the player’s choice of which — Attuned items included (Attunement Stress releases at the start of their next Activation, as for any lost item). It is gone, not destroyed; it may wash up somewhere the tide put it, at the GM’s word. A Priest holding nothing loses half the coin they carry instead. | Something, or someone, drifts out of reach. |
The lasting change carries no mechanics. Write it on the sheet beside Encroachment each time the tab comes due: it is the slow change a long life of channelling makes, and the line a player reads back years later to see what the faith has cost.
Reading the table at a glance. The Prices are deliberately unequal in shape and roughly equal in weight. Strategy and Law cost a scene; Trickery and Winter cost until the next Long Rest; Sea costs gear; Mercy costs someone else; Death costs nothing today and may cost everything later. A held Death Mark is the sharpest single risk on the table: alone, rolling +1 against TN 8, a Priest survives a Bleed-Out about 65% of the time with no held Marks, 44% with one, and 20% with two.
A Priest at Faith 6 — the mortal ceiling, reachable only through Advancement and only with Will at 3 — stands at the practical ceiling of Novice-tier Faith — Encroachment from a Fail becomes mathematically impossible outside a Snake Eyes roll. This is intended: Certainty is what Faith is buying at that investment level, and the math re-introduces risk on its own at Adept (TN 10) and Master (TN 12) without needing a separate rule to force it. Locked Stress cost is unaffected either way — a Priest cannot cast for free regardless of tier.
The Attrition
A Priest can perfectly heal the party and strip the armour off bosses, but every time they do, they step closer to their own breaking point — on two separate clocks. Stress is the fast one: when a Priest maxes out their Stress track, they cannot cast anymore without suffering physical Wounds, per the Death Spiral rule. Encroachment is the slow one: even a Priest who manages their Stress carefully and never Breaks can still be run down by an accumulation of Fails alone, four bad rolls from an empty tab — always with their Domain’s Price waiting at the end, never with a Locked Stress figure to negotiate against.
Flowing (Maintaining a Prayer)
A Prayer with an ongoing duration is said to be Flowing — the authority is still running through the Priest, and has not yet been set down. Holding it open turn after turn is its own ongoing negotiation.
-
The Faith Cost: Because the Priest already paid the Locked Stress upfront at the moment of casting, keeping a Prayer Flowing requires no additional Stress payment of any kind. However, at the start of each of their Activations while it Flows, the Priest must roll 2d6 + Faith vs. the Prayer’s own TN to maintain their grip on the borrowed authority.
-
Pass: The Prayer keeps Flowing. No further cost.
-
Fail: The Prayer keeps Flowing anyway (Faith does not simply drop the way a failed Arcane Sustain check does) — but the Priest gains 1 point of Encroachment, exactly as with a fresh cast. The longer a Priest white-knuckles a Flowing Prayer through failed rolls, the closer they creep toward paying for it in flesh.
-
Snake Eyes: The Prayer keeps Flowing, but the Priest takes 1 direct Wound as their body pays a toll for staying tethered to something that doesn’t want to let go, and their Encroachment resets to 0 as that toll is paid in full.
-
The Physical Anchor: Regardless of the roll, if the Priest takes a Wound or is knocked Prone, the Flowing Prayer still instantly drops. Divine connection still requires absolute physical devotion — the dice govern the cost of staying tethered, not whether the tether can be physically severed.
Sustain and Flowing, side by side. Both cost no Locked Stress and both are limited to one at a time. An Arcanist rolls to find out whether they keep the spell; a Priest rolls to find out what holding on costs them. A failed Arcane Sustain ends the spell. A failed Flowing check never does — but it writes another line on the tab. Conversely, a Wound only tests an Arcanist’s concentration, while a Wound or a fall severs a Priest’s connection outright, no roll offered.